Pagley's Pasta & More

Pagley's Pasta & More: New Castle's Family-Owned Italian Treasure

Pagley's Pasta & More brings authentic Italian-American comfort food to New Castle with homemade pasta, rich sauces, and the kind of cozy neighborhood hospitality that spans generations. This family-owned restaurant on East Washington Street has become a community gathering place where red-checkered tablecloths, family photos, and the aroma of garlic and tomatoes create an atmosphere of genuine warmth. The generous portions and homemade quality keep locals coming back decade after decade.

The dining room exudes authentic Italian-American charm—red-checkered tablecloths, family photos on the walls, and Italian music playing softly. The smell of garlic, tomatoes, and fresh-baked bread fills the air. The cozy neighborhood feel makes every guest feel like part of the family.

• Chicken Parmesan: Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and melted mozzarella, served over spaghetti.
• Homemade Pasta: Fresh pasta with that slightly chewy, substantial texture, served with rich meat sauce.
• Italian Wedding Soup: Loaded with tiny meatballs, pasta, and greens in savory chicken broth.
• Stromboli & Pizza: Rolled and baked until golden, stuffed with cheese and meats.

The portions are genuinely large—one meal easily becomes two. The homemade sauces are a point of pride and elevate every dish. Takeout is popular with locals who know the quality travels well.

Practical Info

Pagley's Pasta & More is open Tuesday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM and Sunday from 12:00 PM to 7:00 PM (closed Mondays). Entrees range from $12 to $20, with generous portions that often provide leftovers. The restaurant is located at 1235 E Washington St, New Castle, PA 16101. Contact: (724) 658-3066.

Q: Is the pasta really homemade?
A: Yes, the pasta is made fresh in-house, giving it that distinctive chewy, substantial texture.

Q: Are portions as large as described?
A: Absolutely—most guests leave with to-go boxes, and many come specifically because one meal provides leftovers.

Q: Is the restaurant family-friendly?
A: The warm, welcoming atmosphere makes it perfect for family dining and special occasions.